The
following is an excerpt taken from the Saturday, May 20, 2006, Post-Journal, Vol. 179, No. 373,
Section C, page 7.
Local
flavor
Artistic
work from authors with area associations
By
ROBERT W. PLYLER
We havenÕt reviewed books or
recordings for several weeks and there are a number, many with local
associations, waiting to be called to your attention.
This week, letÕs turn our
attention to the literary and recorded music:
Doctors
from Hell
ItÕs always a source of
disappointment when someone acts in a way unworthy of human behavior, but it is
especially angering when the evil-doer is someone who is entrusted to do good.
The Robert H. Jackson Center in
downtown Jamestown, has had scheduled for some time, a lecture by author Vivien
Spitz regarding her book Doctors from Hell. Unfortunately, the Jackson
Center has recently received word that Ms. Spitz has experienced health
problems and will not be able to keep her appointment with Jamestown in the
coming week.
Nonetheless, weÕve read her book
and would like to share our observations with you. The wonderful thing about
the published word is that it lives and is available, around the clock, no
matter what befalls its author.
In 1945, Vivien Spitz was 22
years old. She had only recently begun a career as a court stenographer, the
year World War II finally came to an end. Among the biggest news, once the
shooting stopped, was the international tribunals, at which those deemed mostly
responsible for the savage inhumanity of HitlerÕs Third Reich were being put on
trial by the winners of the war.
On trial were the men who planned
the invasions of peaceful countries, created the weapons which killed millions,
devoted their factories, railroads and other property to criminal aggression
and especially those who carried out the deliberate murder of millions of
innocent people.
While it could never be said they
didnÕt do anything wrong, it was clearly true that these people hadnÕt done
anything illegal. There was no law in their country against what they did and
indeed, most of them had been ordered by their government to do the things they
did.
But, the winners of the war
believed that there are some things which are so bad that no one should
consider doing them. At Nuremburg, Germany, the Nazi leaders were put on trial,
and many of them were imprisoned or executed, not for breaking any law, but for
violating the spirit of simple human decency.
The first trials held were of the
government leaders, the names which had filled the headlines, ever since the
Nazis had come to power in Germany. Robert H. Jackson, born just across the
Pennsylvania line from Jamestown, who began his career as a lawyer in
Jamestown, and to whom the Jackson Center is dedicated, was asked by President
Truman to temporarily leave the Supreme Court, where he was an associate
justice and to serve as the chief prosecutor of these Nazi leaders.
Many people donÕt know that when
the first trial was over, the tribunals continued to meet at Nuremburg. Ms.
SpitzÕs book gives us some idea of what it was like to live and work Nuremburg,
a city which was once at the heart of a bitter enemy, now lying in rubble from
the bombing and attacks of our own troops.
The author tells us she had
previously had some experience in being a court reporter in trials involving
medical situations, so she was assigned to the tribunal which tried German
doctors who had performed savage and immoral experiments on the bodies of men,
women and children who had found their way onto the NazisÕ lists of ÔÔhuman
waste.ÕÕ
The accounts of people being
injected with infections to see if various medications worked in treating them,
thrown into tanks of nearly freezing water, to see how long pilots downed in
icy water could be expected to survive and what techniques best restored them
to health, and a seemingly endless list of such experiments, make it hard to
believe that common criminals could do such inhuman things, let alone people
trained to provide health and healing.
Doctors from Hell is not easy reading. The
words are simple, direct and easy to understand, but the longer one reads about
these doctors and their inhumanity, the lower oneÕs faith in humanity tends to
fall.
In 1945, when the horrors of the
Holocaust were made public, many Germans were shocked, that their countryÕs
doings were so much worse than they had imagined. Many were consumed with guilt
that they had overlooked the sure signs of what was taking place at Auschwitz,
Dachau and Bergen-Belsen.
And yet the people who had
participated in the mass murder and torture did not have a big red dot in the
middle of their foreheads. The staff of the tribunals constantly lived with the
knowledge that the waiter in their cafe or the person who came in to clean up
the courtroom might have been one of the guilty.
As she goes systematically from
case to case, she occasionally interjects information about where she was
living, under what conditions. She gives her personal observations of both the
troops and the defeated German people.
The book is documentation, rather
than an attention-holding narration. ItÕs greatest effect is to erode the
natural numbing which occurs in our minds when we think about the Nazi era. The
term ÔÔa million murdersÕÕ means something intellectually, but doesnÕt truly register
in our understanding.
This book starts with ÔÔmurder
number oneÕÕ and continues until there is no choice but to remember.
Doctors from Hell was published in 2005, by
First Sentient Publications, of Boulder, CO. It has 290 pages, in hardcover edition,
not including documentation, informative appendices and bibliography. It sells
for $23.95. Look for ISBN number 1-59181-032-9.
Also worthy of note, Ms. Spitz
has made it a life mission to speak out against those people who try to deny or
minimalize the facts of the Holocaust, realizing that people who saw these
things with their own eyes are now in their 80s, and will soon be no longer
around to speak the truth which she saw with her own eyes. That is why she has
chosen to go case by case by case, even though it becomes repetitive and is
difficult to bear, for the reader.
We regret she has been unable to
speak to us at the Jackson Center, in the coming week.